Skip to content

The Greatest Shrimp Scampi (Recipe Critiques)

Shrimp scampi is a basic, and for good motive: It is easy, scrumptious, and stress-free. You simply sautéed some shrimp; hit it with aromatics like garlic, spicy pink pepper flakes, white wine, and lemon juice; after which toss with pasta. The dish comes collectively rapidly, bursts with taste, and makes any meal really feel like a celebration. Make shrimp scampi for dinner and watch how rapidly folks’s eyes gentle up; it is simply feels particular.

However there are numerous variations on the dish. Some recipes use butter, some add shallots, some use a lot of wine, and others skip the wine altogether. Relying on whom you ask, the recipe might be made with as little as 5 components — or as many as 20.

That is why I made a decision to check 4 fashionable shrimp scampi recipes in a head-to-head battle to see which one is the perfect. I examined one with out wine, one which took greater than an hour to make, one which makes use of thyme and shallots, and one which doubles down on the butter. On the finish of the seafood-filled day I discovered a brand new scampi recipe that has turn out to be a brand new go-to weeknight dinner.

Meet Our 4 Shrimp Scampi Contenders

For this showdown I made a decision that any shrimp scampi recipe — no matter whether or not it was served on pasta or not — was honest sport. I’d be tasting every scampi by itself, then with pasta, and judging them accordingly. From there I searched the web for a few of the hottest and beloved recipes I might discover.

Ina Garten: In contrast to most shrimp scampi recipes, Ina skips the white wine and subs in additional lemon juice. She provides slices of entire lemons and tosses the saucy shrimp with linguine. With greater than 1,000 evaluations and a five-star common ranking, I used to be excited to check out her distinctive method from her.

Fundamentals with Babish: Babish (the Youtube celeb recognized for his viral cooking movies) has two recipes for scampi on his website: a easy model and a extra advanced one. His advanced model of him is made with shrimp shell-infused wine, contemporary herbs, toasted breadcrumbs, and a handful of different intelligent upgrades. The recipe seemed like loads of effort, however I used to be excited to see if the outcomes could be definitely worth the work.

Cafe Delites: This is likely one of the hottest scampi recipes on-line. The recipe is tremendous easy and comes collectively very quickly. It requires fewer than 10 components and requires no particular tools or additional steps. The recipe seemed precisely like what I imagined after I heard shrimp scampi — lemony, buttery, and wealthy — so I knew I wanted to provide it a attempt.

lydia bastianich: Lidia is a beloved professional of Italian delicacies and I absolutely belief any recipe she writes. Her recipe from Ella requires just a few distinctive additions, like contemporary thyme, shallots, and a hefty quantity of white wine. The recipe gave the impression of it could be full of taste, so I used to be excited to see how it could rank.

How I Examined the Shrimp Scampi Recipes

Every shrimp scampi recipe was made precisely as written. Every scampi was made on the identical day, tasted as is, then tossed with pasta and tasted as soon as extra. I judged the recipes based mostly on taste and ease of preparation. On the finish of the day one scampi stood out among the many recipes and was topped the winner.

1. The Excessive-Effort, Medium-Reward Recipe: Babish’s “Advanced” Shrimp Scampi

Whereas this recipe was scrumptious, it was loads of effort in comparison with the opposite recipes — and I am unsure that the outcomes had been definitely worth the work. The recipe referred to as for a laundry listing of components and it took me about an hour to make it. The addition of toasted panko breadcrumbs added a pleasant pop of texture that I liked, however apart from that the pasta did not wow me. Do not get me mistaken, I’d fortunately eat this any day of the week — however I am simply too lazy to make this once more and would most likely make his less complicated scampi recipe subsequent time.

2. The Scrumptious (however Barely Untraditional) Shrimp Scampi: Ina Garten’s Linguine with Shrimp Scampi

Whereas I liked how this recipe tasted, it did not really feel like a standard scampi to me. The pasta tasted extra like a lemony shrimp linguine than a basic scampi. By omitting the white wine, you take away loads of the intense complexity that normally comes with scampi. And the addition of entire lemon slices and lemon juice added a double hit of lemon taste that overwhelmed the pasta a bit. I did not dislike this pasta in any respect — in actual fact, I ate most of it — I simply do not suppose it tastes like a basic scampi.

3. The Tremendous-Easy Runner-Up: Cafe Delites’ Shrimp Scampi

In the event you’re on the lookout for a fast, no-fuss shrimp scampi recipe, that is for you. It has all the basic, shiny flavors of shrimp scampi with no laundry listing of components. It takes simply half-hour to make and is garlicky, wealthy, and excellent for tossing with pasta. A beneficiant quantity of butter provides richness, whereas white wine cuts by means of the fats and makes it shine. After I consider a basic shrimp scampi recipe, that is precisely what I consider.

4. The Clear Winner: Lidia Bastianich’s Shrimp Scampi

This recipe was absolute perfection. It was shiny, acidic, and bursting with taste, because of shallots and thyme. The recipe takes barely extra effort than most, however can nonetheless be made in about half-hour and with out a lot fuss. Lidia has you make a shallot and garlic paste that you just prepare dinner down after searing the shrimp. That additional step gave the scampi a savory basis that took the recipe to the following degree. It was garlicky, barely candy, and complicated. I additionally liked that this recipe made loads of sauce. The shrimp are virtually swimming within the buttery white wine sauce that is good for tossing with pasta or dipping bread into. I might fortunately eat this on daily basis of the week.

Do you could have a favourite shrimp scampi recipe? Tell us within the feedback!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *